Your therapist sees yet another problem with the world and tries to understand it.
Two things kept turning up in my feed in the same fortnight: himpathy, and the NDA. They turn out to be closely related.
Himpathy
The philosopher Kate Manne coined the word in Down Girl (2017). It names the disproportionate sympathy powerful men receive when they’re accused of sexual violence, and the way the women they harmed quietly drop out of the story. Everyone’s attention goes to him: his career, his reputation, his feelings, his future (insert your own). Her experience slides out of focus.
Russell Brand is the obvious example this month. When the allegations first surfaced in 2023, he framed them as a coordinated attack by the mainstream media, and plenty of people were happy to go along with that (Elon Musk replied to his video: “Of course. They don’t like competition.”). Earlier this month a jury convicted him of rape and three counts of sexual assault involving four women, and acquitted him on the other counts. Six women came forward, independently of one another, and for three years so much of the public conversation was about him.
Here’s where my therapist brain goes, though. I think himpathy is a deeply human problem, and an old one.
The psychoanalyst Ronald Fairbairn described what he called the moral defence. A child hurt by the person they depend on often decides the badness must be theirs, so the adult can stay good and the attachment stays safe. Himpathy looks to me like the grown-up, collective version. It’s so painful to accept that someone we admired, laughed with or trusted did harm that we protect the image and hand the badness to the person who got hurt.
It’s far from limited to celebrities. Workplaces do it too. A valued colleague is accused, and somehow the person who spoke up becomes the problem. Psychologists Carly Smith and Jennifer Freyd call this institutional betrayal (American Psychologist, 2014): trusted institutions harming the very people who depend on them for safety.
What himpathy needs: silence
Then this week’s headlines. A young woman connected to allegations against a well-known figure (allegations he denies) reportedly said she had signed a non-disclosure agreement. It stopped her from speaking to the media, to her family and friends, and to her therapist.
Her therapist (!!).
Judith Herman put it plainly in Trauma and Recovery: “Secrecy and silence are the perpetrator’s first line of defense.” Himpathy needs exactly that silence to keep working.
In therapy, truth arrives slowly (or completely abruptly, mind you!). Most often, though, it comes in pieces: an image on the page, a sentence started and abandoned, the body speaking before language catches up. Those pieces get gathered at whatever pace a person can bear. Often it’s rehearsing the truth in the therapy room that makes telling it anywhere else possible. A clause that shuts the therapy room door shuts a lot of other doors with it.
What the law says now
Since 1 October 2025, section 17 of the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 means an NDA can’t stop a victim of crime in England and Wales (or someone who reasonably believes they are one) from talking to certain people about what happened. That includes the police, lawyers, and regulated professionals, regulated healthcare professionals among them, when the purpose is getting support.
There are two catches. First, it isn’t retroactive: agreements signed before 1 October 2025 still sit under the older, murkier rules. Second, “regulated” is doing a lot of work. Government guidance says disclosures to non-regulated professionals fall outside this protection. As an HCPC-registered art psychotherapist, I’d count. Many counsellors and psychotherapists on voluntary registers may not, and that’s a gap to know about if you’re choosing a therapist while bound by an agreement. (I’m not a lawyer, so if this is you, please get proper legal advice.)
So who is being protected?
A reputation, mostly, and the brand built on it.
And who carries the cost? Usually the youngest, least powerful person in the arrangement.
A lot of therapy is slowly handing the badness back to where it belongs. Clauses like these make it harder for that work to even begin.
Have you come across this before? And for fellow therapists: has it ever come up in your practice?